• Blog
  • Calculators
    • Camera Bitrate Converter | Record Time Calculator
    • Diffraction Calculator
    • DoF Calculator | Lens Equivalent
    • Shutter Speed to Shutter Angle Calculator
  • Memory Cards
    • SD Memory Cards Guide
    • CFExpress Type-B Memory Card Benchmarks
    • CFexpress Type-A Memory Card Benchmarks
    • Memory Cards For Canon Cameras
    • Memory Cards For Fujifilm Cameras
    • Memory Cards For Nikon Cameras
    • Memory Cards For Panasonic Cameras
    • Memory Cards For Sony
    • SD Cards For GoPro
  • Accessories
    • Canon
      • Canon R5 Accessories
      • Canon R6 Accessories
      • Canon EOS R
      • Canon RP
      • Canon M50 Accessories
      • Canon T7i / T6 / T6i / T6s
      • Canon SL3 / 250D
      • Canon M6 II
      • Canon M5
      • Canon G1X III
      • Canon G7X III
    • Nikon
      • Nikon Z9
      • Nikon Z6 II / Z7 II
      • Nikon Z6 / Z7
      • Nikon Z50
    • Fujifilm
      • Fujifilm X-H2s
      • Fujifilm X-H2
      • Fujifilm X-T5
      • Fujifilm X-T4
      • Fujifilm X-S10
      • Fujifilm X-Pro3
      • Fujifilm X-T3
      • Fujifilm X-H1
      • Fujifilm X-T200
      • Fujifilm X100V Accessories
      • Fujifilm X100F Accessories
      • Fujifilm X-E4
      • Fujifilm XT30 & XT20
    • Leica
      • Leica M11 Accessories
      • Leica Q2 Accessories
    • Panasonic
      • Panasonic GH5 / GH5s
      • Panasonic LX100 II
    • Ricoh
      • Ricoh GR III
    • Sigma
      • Sigma fp
    • Sony
      • Sony A1 Accessories
      • Sony A7IV Accessories
      • Sony A7c Accessories
      • Sony A7sIII
      • Sony A7rIV / A9II
      • Sony A9
      • Sony A7 III, A7r III Accessories
      • Sony A6600 Accessories
      • Sony A6100 Accessories
      • Sony A6000 Accessories
      • Sony RX1R II
      • Sony RX10 IV / RX10 III
      • Sony RX100 IV / RX100 V
    • Drones
      • Mavic 2 Pro
    • Camera Cleaning Gear
  • Lenses
    • Canon RF Lens List
    • Fujifilm G Lens List
    • Fujifilm XF Lens List
    • Leica / Panasonic / Sigma L Lens List
    • Leica M Lens List
    • Micro Four Thirds Lens List
    • Nikon Z Lens List
    • PL Mount Cine Lens List
    • Sony FF E Lens List
    • Sony APS-C E Lens List
  • Store
Alik Griffin
Alik Griffin
  • Blog
  • Calculators
    • Camera Bitrate Converter | Record Time Calculator
    • Diffraction Calculator
    • DoF Calculator | Lens Equivalent
    • Shutter Speed to Shutter Angle Calculator
  • Memory Cards
    • SD Memory Cards Guide
    • CFExpress Type-B Memory Card Benchmarks
    • CFexpress Type-A Memory Card Benchmarks
    • Memory Cards For Canon Cameras
    • Memory Cards For Fujifilm Cameras
    • Memory Cards For Nikon Cameras
    • Memory Cards For Panasonic Cameras
    • Memory Cards For Sony
    • SD Cards For GoPro
  • Accessories
    • Canon
      • Canon R5 Accessories
      • Canon R6 Accessories
      • Canon EOS R
      • Canon RP
      • Canon M50 Accessories
      • Canon T7i / T6 / T6i / T6s
      • Canon SL3 / 250D
      • Canon M6 II
      • Canon M5
      • Canon G1X III
      • Canon G7X III
    • Nikon
      • Nikon Z9
      • Nikon Z6 II / Z7 II
      • Nikon Z6 / Z7
      • Nikon Z50
    • Fujifilm
      • Fujifilm X-H2s
      • Fujifilm X-H2
      • Fujifilm X-T5
      • Fujifilm X-T4
      • Fujifilm X-S10
      • Fujifilm X-Pro3
      • Fujifilm X-T3
      • Fujifilm X-H1
      • Fujifilm X-T200
      • Fujifilm X100V Accessories
      • Fujifilm X100F Accessories
      • Fujifilm X-E4
      • Fujifilm XT30 & XT20
    • Leica
      • Leica M11 Accessories
      • Leica Q2 Accessories
    • Panasonic
      • Panasonic GH5 / GH5s
      • Panasonic LX100 II
    • Ricoh
      • Ricoh GR III
    • Sigma
      • Sigma fp
    • Sony
      • Sony A1 Accessories
      • Sony A7IV Accessories
      • Sony A7c Accessories
      • Sony A7sIII
      • Sony A7rIV / A9II
      • Sony A9
      • Sony A7 III, A7r III Accessories
      • Sony A6600 Accessories
      • Sony A6100 Accessories
      • Sony A6000 Accessories
      • Sony RX1R II
      • Sony RX10 IV / RX10 III
      • Sony RX100 IV / RX100 V
    • Drones
      • Mavic 2 Pro
    • Camera Cleaning Gear
  • Lenses
    • Canon RF Lens List
    • Fujifilm G Lens List
    • Fujifilm XF Lens List
    • Leica / Panasonic / Sigma L Lens List
    • Leica M Lens List
    • Micro Four Thirds Lens List
    • Nikon Z Lens List
    • PL Mount Cine Lens List
    • Sony FF E Lens List
    • Sony APS-C E Lens List
  • Store
  • Blog
  • Lens Reviews
  • Reviews

Fujifilm 23mm f1.4 vs. 23mm f2 | Lens Comparison

  • May 2, 2019
  • AGriffin

If you are on the fence about which lens to buy, the Fujifilm 23mm f1.4 or the Fujifilm 23mm f2, this comparison will guide you through the differences between the two. I also share my personal take on which lens I prefer and for what since I find them both useful, but for different situations.

 

 

Fujifilm 23mm f1.4 vs 23mm f2 Lens Comparison

 

It might seem like the Fujinon 23mm f2 is a stop slower, but it actually has a lot more going for it in terms of specs. 9 aperture blades vs 7, weather sealed, silent focus etc. The 23mm f2 is really more of a casual lens while the 23mm f1.4 is more of a pro portrait lens.

Lens Stats – 23mm f1.4 Lens Stats – 23mm f2

35mm Equiv – 35mm
Aperture Range – f1.4 – f16
Minimum Focus Range – 11.02″ (28 cm)
Aperture Blades – 7 Rounded
Design – 11 elements in 8 groups – 1 aspherical
Coating: Multi-Layer HT-EBC
Weather Sealed: No
Filter Threads: 62mm
Focus Type: High-Torque DC Coreless
Weight: 10.6 oz
List Price: $899

Fujifilm 23mm f1.4 Review

Order – Amazon / Adorama / BHphoto

35mm Equiv – 35mm
Aperture Range – f2 – f16
Minimum Focus Range – 8.66″ (22 cm)
Aperture Blades – 9 Rounded
Design – 10 elements in 6 groups – 2 aspherical
Coating: Super EBC Coating
Weather Sealed: Yes
Filter Threads: 43mm
Focus Type: Stepping Motor (Silent)
Weight: 6.35 oz
List Price: $399

Fujifilm 23mm f2 Review

Order – Amazon / Adorama / BHphoto

 

Lenses For Fuji X Mount

 

Sharpness Comparison

Both lenses are very sharp but the Fujinon 23mm f1.4 is a touch sharper in the center. The f1.4 does however suffer a bit more from diffraction at those higher apertures. This could be because my lens is older now and has some dust inside.

 

 

 

Corners are better on the 23mm f1.4 but not by a lot. The f1.4 lens does have less of a shift in the colors and isn’t hit as hard by vignetting. At f2, the Fujinon 23mm f2 performs better when looking at sharpness alone.

This is my second copy of the Fujinon 23mm f1.4 and my last copy (before it died) was a little bit better in the corners. My new copy is very slightly decentered so it may be possible to get better results than this with a new 23mm f1.4.

 

 

Here is a closer view of each lenses sharpness chart as seen on their review pages.

Fujinon 23mm f1.4 Center Sharpness
Fujinon 23mm f1.4 Corner Sharpness
Fujinon 23mm f2 Center Sharpness
Fujinon 23mm f2 Center Sharpness
Fujinon 23mm f2 Corner Sharpness
Fujinon 23mm f2 Corner Sharpness

 

Distortion Comparison

Both lenses have a very minor distortion. I stripped the in-camera profile corrections in Iridient and do not see any artificial distortion correction on either lens.

The 23mm f2 has some very subtle distortion, while the 23mm f1.4 has almost no distortion.

 

23mm f1.4
Fujinon 23mm f2 Distortion
23mm f2

 

 

Vignetting Comparison

While both lenses look to have very little vignetting, you’re not seeing the full pictures. The in-camera lens profile correction is removing most of the Fujinon 23mm f2 vignetting, which is not great.

While you might be thinking that the camera removing the vignetting is a good thing, you’ll have to realize that by removing the vignetting, the shadows are essentially being lifted in those edges and you’ll get less dynamic range and tonal details that could affect the quality of your images if you need to lift the exposure.

You’ll have less ability for shadow recovery along the edges and corners with the Fujinon 23mm f2 because of this correction. 

For most people, this won’t make a difference, but if you’re shooting low light photography it will affect your dynamic range along the corners and edges at those faster apertures where it’s a problem.

 

This is vignetting wide open with the lens profile correction removed. It’s mostly gone on the 23mm f2 lens by f4. The Fujinon 23mm f1.4 looks great by f2. My vignetting is a little uneven here because I was shooting the sky.

 

Fujinon 23mm f1.4 Vignetting
Fujinon 23mm f2 Vignetting
Fujinon 23mm f2 Vignetting

 

Bokeh Comparison

Since sharpness and corner sharpness is mostly comparable as well as distortion, the difference between these two lenses is down to the bokeh and low light performance. This is what you’re paying more than twice the money for.

f1.4 is a full stop brighter than f2. You’ll also get much shallower depth of field, which you can now calculate using the depth of field calculator.

 

With the 23mm f1.4, at 2 feet (61 cm)  you get about 1.5″ (3.78 cm) of depth. Compared to f2 where you get 2.13″ (5.41 cm) of depth. 

 

In terms of bokeh style, you’ll notice the Fujinon 23mm f1.4 has a cleaner smoother bokeh when wide open. The 23mm f2 has nice bokeh as well, but in some situations it will produce some coma and give you a swirling effect. Sometimes this is cool, sometimes it can be very distracting. 

 

ISO 200, f1.4, 1/2700
ISO 200, f2, 1/1500
ISO 200, f1.4, 1/3000
ISO 200, f2, 1/1400
ISO 200, f1.4, 1/3200
ISO 200, f2, 1/1700
ISO 200, f1.4, 1/5000
ISO 200, f2, 1/2000
ISO 200, f1.4, 1/9000
ISO 200, f2,, 1/5400
ISO 200, f1.4, 1/5400
ISo 200, f2, 1/2500
ISO 200, f1.4, 1/110
ISO 200, f2, 1/80
ISO 200, f1.4, 1/4400
ISO 200, f2, 1/2400
ISO 200, f1.4, 1/200
ISO 200, f2, 1/100
ISO 200, f1.4, 1/160
ISO 200, f2, 1/80

 

Coma / Edge Bokeh

The Fujinon 23mm f1.4 has pretty nice bokeh balls along the edges while the 23mm f2 has some pretty noticeable coma. You’ll also see some minor swirl on the 23mm f2 but it’s not as bad as the Fujinon 35mm f2 or the 50mm f2.

 

ISO 200, f1.4, 1/680
ISO 200, f2, 1/280

 

Color / Micro-Contrast / Contrast

When looking at image fidelity at f5.6 and mid apertures, the 23mm f2 actually has slightly better color rendering, contrast and also better micro-contrast than the 23mm f1.4. This is actually something I noticed right away without even doing side by sides. Images just pop off the screen with almost a 3d realism with the f2. This makes it look like the 23mm f2 images are sharper because of the better tonal depth. Keep in mind, the difference isn’t huge, but it’s there.

When comparing both lenses wide open, the results are a bit closer.

This is not saying the 23mm f1.4 doesn’t have great pop, it does, it’s just not as good as the 23mm f2.

What this means is if you’re looking to buy your first prime lenses after shooting with a zoom, the 23mm f2 will give you a good demonstration of the quality and beauty of prime lenses over zoom lenses without spending a ton of money.

The Fujinon 23mm f2 tends to also render a little bit warmer. I did shoot all these samples side-by-side with the 23mm f2 on the X-Pro2 and the 23mm f1.4 on the X-T2, so I’m not totally sure if this is from the camera or the lens.

You’ll also notice in these samples that the 23mm f2 produces an image that is a few mm wider than the 23mm f1.4.

These are half-size and I corrected color temperatures to match, but you can see how the f2 has a little bit more punch at f5.6.

Fujinon 23mm f1.4
Fujinon 23mm f2

 

Autofocus & Manual Focus Comparison

Mechanically the focus system between the two lenses works completely different. With the 23mm f1.4 lens, front barrel expands when focusing where as the 23mm f2 focuses an internal element.

Autofocus on the older 23mm f1.4 uses a high-torque DC coreless system where as the 23mm f2 uses a completely silent stepping motor.

The difference is the old High-Torque DC Coreless is a bit slower. It hunts and pecks a little more, misses more and makes more noise. The Stepping motor on the 23mm f2 is almost instantaneous. It’s noticeably faster and will also be much better for video since it is silent. The 23mm f2 should also have the latest focusing micro-computer which is said to help with contrast detect autofocus.

The 23mm f1.4 speed and acquisition is fine for most styles of photography, I do like to use my 23mm f2 when shooting my kids all cracked out on sugar as AF-C is noticeably snappier. It really makes a difference when you’re talking about shots that are almost in focus vs shots that are perfectly in focus. You’ll especially notice it if you’re on the X-T3 and using eye tracking as your subject is running towards you. But again, portraits, wedding, landscape the 23mm f1.4 is fine especially with the X-T3 which fixes a lot of the hunting and pecking.

 

Manual Focus

When switching between manual and autofocus on the 23mm f1.4, the focus ring snaps into the different modes. When the lens is in manual focus or autofocus mode, you will only be able to use that mode no matter how you have the camera set. A few Fujinon lenses are like this and it’s a little confusing to get use to.

With the 23mm f2, auto focus and manual focus is controlled by the camera and there are no settings on the lens.

Both lenses have a fly-by-wire manual focus system. With the X-T3, you can set this up to be linear focus which allows the lens to function more like a manual focus lens. When trying to focus with precision, you’ll still see the little steps as you adjust focus which makes extreme precision difficult.

 

Minimum Focus Distance

You will notice the Fujinon 23mm f2 has a much closer minimum focus distance. The Fujinon 23mm f1.4 has a minimum focus distance of 11.02″ (28 cm), while the Fujinon 23mm f2 has a minimum focus distance of 8.66″ (22 cm).

The difference isn’t huge as the minimum focus distance on the 23mm 1.4 is still pretty good. But here’s the thing; if you’re closer and focusing on small objects, you can get the Fujinon 23mm f2 to have more extreme bokeh than the 23mm f1.4 even though the f2 is a full stop slower simply because those few inches will allow for a shallower depth.

So if you’re shooting subjects extremely close to the lens, the Fujinon 23mm f2 will actually give you shallower depth.

Here is a sample.

ISO 200, f1.4, 1/160
ISO 200, f2, 1/80

 

Flaring

I can’t really get these lenses to flare with any significance. The Fujinon 23mm f1.4 has a Multi-Layer HT-EBC lens coating while the Fujinon 23mm f2 has a Super EBC coating.

While I’m sure there is some chemist that works at Fujifilm that could tell you the difference between these two, in real world shooting I’m definitely not seeing one. 

 

 

Build Quality

 

When comparing the two lenses physically, build quality is noticeably different. The 23mm f1.4 is bigger, it’s heavier, from my experience it’s more fragile. The 23mm f2 is noticeably smaller and lighter and won’t tip over your camera from being too front heavy when set on a desk. It’s also weather resistant making it a great adventure lens. The 23mm f1.4 also has the autofocus to manual focus clutch mentioned above.

I’ve dropped my 23mm f2 Fujinon lens on concrete from waist-high without any terrible consequences. While I don’t recommend doing that, accidents happen. If you drop your 23mm f1.4 from waist-high while it’s in a backpack, like you open the back of your SUV and your backpack falls out with your lens somewhere inside . . . expect the worst.

 

 

My first 23mm f1.4 started having element issues and stopped produce sharp images when wide open after a few months. My backpack once fell out of my car with the lens inside and I use to cycle with it in my back back, so vibrations and impacts are not friendly to this lens. So be careful with that one.

I always make sure I have good copies for reviews, so your lenses should perform as good as what I’ve shown here.

 

 

 

Fuji 23mm f1.4 vs 23mm f2 | Bottom Line

 

If you’re on the fence between these two lenses, your decision should depend on what style of photography you shoot and what you plan on using the lenses for. A lot of people may actually want both lenses.

If you’re solely want to shoot photos for the sake of art and don’t mind a lens that’s slower with autofocus, heavier and a little less resilient, then the 23mm f1.4 will be the lens for you. It’s also better in low light.

If you need more of an adventure lens, have kids and just need to get the shot, while still having a lighter build and weather sealing, the 23mm f2 will be the obvious choice. It’s such an incredible value. You get a silent, incredibly fast focusing weather sealed lens with amazing color and pop for around $400.

Before I had kids, I found the 23mm f1.4 to be fantastic, it’s all I ever needed. Now I have two kids, am biking more and am doing a lot more run and gun shooting to capture daily life and street photography and I’m finding myself grabbing the 23mm f2 lens more than the f1.4.

I also shoot frequently at slower apertures to get more of the scene in focus for landscape or street style photography. At the slower apertures like f5.6, there really isn’t a huge difference between these two lenses. So again, the 23mm f2 makes a lot of sense for me, especially when traveling.

 

 

Fujinon 23mm f1.4 Sample Photos

ISO 400, f5.6, 1/600
ISO 200, f1.4, 1/11000
ISO 400, f5.6, 1/300
ISO 160, f1.4, 1/3200
ISO 160, f1.4, 1/110

 

Fujinon 23mm f2 Sample Photos

ISO 160, f2, 1/1000
ISO 160, f2, 1/1900
ISO 160, f8, 1/140
ISO 160, f2, 1/125
ISO 160, f2, 1/680
ISO 160, f2, 1/150
ISO 160, f2, 1/1900
**This website contains affiliate links and I will be compensated if you click them to make a purchase.
AGriffin

Professional editor, blogger and photographer from Los Angeles California.

Related Topics
  • Fujinon 23mm f1.4
  • Fujinon 23mm f2
  • Lens Comparison
You May Also Like
New Lexar CFexpress Type B Cards
View Post
  • Accessory Reviews
  • Blog
  • Memory Cards
  • Reviews

Lexar 512GB Diamond & 2TB Gold CFxB Cards – Review & Benchmarks

  • AGriffin
  • March 24, 2023
View Post
  • Blog
  • Lens Reviews
  • Reviews

Voigtlander 50mm f1.5 II Review & Sample Photos

  • AGriffin
  • March 25, 2023
View Post
  • Blog
  • Lens Reviews
  • Reviews

Nikon Z 28mm f2.8 Review & Sample Photos

  • AGriffin
  • February 15, 2023
View Post
  • Accessory Reviews
  • Blog
  • Reviews

Tiffen Black Pro Mist Review – Is This The One?

  • AGriffin
  • February 18, 2023

IG Landscapes @alikgriffin

IG Streets @griffinalik

Twitter Feed
It's happening. This is a photo from almost 2014 shot on the original A7r with the Sony Zeiss 35mm f2.8. Such an un… https://t.co/gSnjcQxvW7
yesterday
  • Reply
  • Retweet
  • Favorite
Follow
Popular Articles
  • New Lexar CFexpress Type B Cards 1
    Lexar 512GB Diamond & 2TB Gold CFxB Cards – Review & Benchmarks
  • 2
    Voigtlander 50mm f1.5 II Review & Sample Photos
  • 3
    Nikon Z 28mm f2.8 Review & Sample Photos
  • 4
    Tiffen Black Pro Mist Review – Is This The One?
  • BB2 Blower Review 5
    NiteCore BB2 Electronic Blower Review
Join The Fun! Sign Up To The Newsletter!


*You will need to confirm your email. Check your spam folder after hitting subscribe.

About Me

A professional freelance trailer editor. I've been blogging for a decade and this site focuses on benchmarking memory cards, camera accessories, and lens reviews. There will be a shift towards more education with color and editing so be sure to hit the bell in the bottom right to subscribe for updates. Read About to learn more.

Popular Lens Reviews
  • 1
    A Complete List Of Fujifilm Lenses | X-Mount
  • Nikon Z 50mm f1.8 S Lens Review 2
    Nikon Z 50mm f1.8 S Lens Review & Sample Photos
  • 3
    Meike 35mm f1.7 Review & Sample Photos
  • 4
    Kamlan 50mm f1.1 II Review & Sample Photos
  • 5
    Meike 35mm f1.4 Review & Sample Photos
Memory Card Guides | Benchmarks

Memory Cards For Canon R5

Memory Cards For Canon R6

Memory Cards For Nikon Z6II / Z7II

Memory Cards For Nikon Z5

Memory Cards For Fujifilm X-T4

Memory Cards For GoPro Hero 9

Memory Cards For GoPro Hero 8

Privacy Policy | Ethics Statement | Licensing

Copyright © Alik Griffin Inc. 2021

Input your search keywords and press Enter.

Manage Cookie Consent

We use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behavior or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.

Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
Manage options Manage services Manage vendors Read more about these purposes
View preferences
{title} {title} {title}